Skip to main content

Monday Update

COMIXTALK

LEGAL BEAGLES

INTERVIEWS

REVIEWS

JUSTIFY MY HYPE

  • I thought David McGuire's Webcomics Are Awesome is pretty funny as a parody of webcomics community (not sure if he's going to update it further) on the level of "lots of this absurd stuff happens and it's always healthy to make fun of yourself" since McGuire is a comic creator himself and as part of the now defunct Bag of Chips collective has certainly been "in" the webcomics community as much as anyone. On the otherhand I don't really know David (met him once at SPX) so I'm not sure how he views this comic.
  • Everyone's making comics about the latest videogame Portal. This one's from Hijinks Ensue (whose creator Joel Watson also makes comics that appear on the website Apple Insider)
  • Tough Guys is a pretty good concept for a comic (or probably more likely an Adult Swim animated series) but the execution of this webcomic by Zac Marshall and Nuno Teixeira is all wrong. The art is strange and largely looks cut and pasted. Maybe a chibi style would have worked better here. It's also largely not funny nor interesting yet. You're aiming at a huge chunk of American pop culture over the last 30 to 40 years (the "action movie") -- that's a big fat softball across the plate, if you're doing jokes you ought to be hitting multiple base hits everytime out.
  • The Tower by Saki Miyamoto and Brendon Bennets is a textless comic about a princess who escapes her intended role in search of adventure.
  • David Wright (creator of Todd and Penguin) has a new webcomic out called The Best Kids Show Ever - sort of if Fox News decided to get into the children's television business.
  • Butternut Squash versus Mahna mahna. (Original muppet song here!)

AROUND THE WORLD IN 80 BLOGS

Re: Monday Update

Lynn Lau's picture

Hi Xaviar!

Just a correction: the Outspoken interview was conducted by guest-interviewer Traci Spencer, not me! Traci's the great talent behind Compass, which runs at Girlamatic.com.

 

Thanks!

Lynn

 

_______________________________________________
http://lynnlau.com
http://tentative.net

_______________________________________________
http://lynnlau.com
http://tentative.net

Tough Guys webcomic

Hey there! I'm the artist behind Tough Guys and I came across this mini review above. I think everything you state in the mini review is legitimate Xaviar. I figure I'd put in some additional words since I'm just new to this whole "making webcomics" thing (if not new to the whole movement as a whole). Any words I can get out there and any words I get back are always helpful if anything I do as an artist can improve.

With that said, this does not mean I'm going to change my style because of one review or one hundred of them. I do on the other hand take every review with an open mind. I initially based the design of the characters off of the chibi style but one thing I won't do or see improving the strip is taking them to the more Japanese chibi style in order to make the strip better. It pretty much is a cut and paste style and I don't think it's attempting to BE anything else. So again, I can understand what you are saying in the review, but I am making a distinct choice to do it in the way that it's being done for many other reasons that aren't important to get in to.

Is it funny? That's up to anyone who reads it, and if it's not funny to you that's fine to; it's just not your kind of strip. There are plenty of famous webcomics out there that are a riot to many and I don't find them at all interesting. Just a matter of taste. I do know the master plan behind the strip from my talks with Zac and I wouldn't be working on this project with him if I didn't believe in the "long term" story behind the strip. Is it a weekly drop-on-the-floor gag strip? Not at all. But the length of the run will make this more obvious then it's current 9 out of 20-something strip introduction. This strip is about the "tough guys" and giving them a personality, not just using them as betters for home runs each time. This is why I'm opting to take the "yet" from the sentence you made and respect that you can at least accept that there MIGHT be a long term story attached to the strip :).

I believe in Zac's knowledge of the content behind this strip. You just have to get him started on the topic to become well aware that he will take every aspect of this strip into account including placing this secret Club on the island of Vale Verde. If you don't know what or where that island is... then you are missing part of the subtle funny behind the writing. I don't think it's Zac or even my attempt to blow everyone away that comes to this strip by no means. We are doing this strip because we have a story to tell and, hell, that's why the webcomic medium is a great place to be: You can do whatever the heck you want, right?

Thanks for the mention!

Re: Tough Guys webcomic

Shoot, I wish this darn thing left paragraph breaks in... Sorry for the seemingly wanton block of text rant :)!