User Friendly and MetaFilter

I saw this on TechDirt recently – the denizens of MetaFilter caught several swipes of comments at MetaFilter turned into the punchlines of User Friendly comics.  The actual MeFi thread is pretty long, and checking out some of the cited examples — it appears that creator J.D. "Illiad" Frasier has deleted several of the comics in his archives as a result (he admits to some of the plagerism in the MeFi thread).

I have no doubt that people accidentally regurgitate punchlines all the time but it’s a pretty bad idea to copy nearly verbatim from others without permission — putting aside any copyright issues, as TechDirt points out it’s going to hurt your reputation.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

The Return of Todd & Penguin

Dave Wright’s Todd and Penguin is back from an unannounced semi-hiatus with a special mystery guest artist penning new strips for the next month. The comic, which returned last week is kicking things off with a contest. The first eight people to guess who the mystery artist is and email the strip’s creator, David Wright (email link found at website), will get a free autographed original comic drawn by the mystery artist. Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Waltz With Bashir

Waltz With Bashir (subtitled "A Lebanon War Story") by Ari Folman and David Polonsky is a graphic novel adaptation of the animated film of the same name.  I have not seen the film yet (although I fully intend to – the trailer looks quite intense).  Ari Folman, wrote, produced, and directed the animated documentary and wrote this graphic novel version as well.  David Polonsky was the art director and chief illustrator for the movie from which the art in the comic comes from (it’s not entirely clear whether the images in the book are altered in any way from their appearance in the movie).  It is Folman’s own story and it appears it is a pretty faithful attempt to chronicle his attempts to fill in his memories of his own military service in the Israel-Lebanan war.

Continue Reading

Tales from Shaun Tan

Tales from Outer Suburbia is the latest book from uber-talented artist Shaun Tan, following his wordless graphic novel, The Arrival.  Tan is not really an experimental cartoonist – these are highly satisfying books that don’t really feel like they’re pushing formalist boundaries and yet his two books each refuse to stay within the expectations of the "graphic novel" format.  I’m not sure Scott McCloud would concede that either one is actually a comic!

Continue Reading

Future of Comics and Webcomics and here we go again – UPDATED

UPDATE AT BOTTOM

An assortment of posts and thoughts on the ever-evolvin' world of comics (with a heavy emphasis on the webby part of it all):

Valerie D'Orazio posts some thoughts about how Marvel and DC might pursue a assimilate and conquer webcomics strategy (I believe she posits it as a 5 year plan).  Joey Manley of various webcomic sites and business plans (disclosure – we use his advertising service on this site) posts some thoughts in response here.  Many, many webcomic creators also replied in D'Orazio's original post.  It's a good discussion.  Here's the thing in a nutshell — if you're creating compelling content you used to have to go through a gatekeeper to get wide distribution.  That's no longer the case with the web.  A big part of a "paper" publisher's business plan (same as with a record company or a movie studio) is leveraging it's access to the platform.  But what I think is possible but it would probably me a much more streamlined and efficient entity than any current publisher is a business plan that provides creative and editorial guidance to a series of projects.  There is still room in this world for a third party to connect ideas with needed writers and artists to produce great comics — but the key difference is that the third party is no longer a publisher in the strictest sense of the word.  They are probably going to be a matchmaker/editor with business savvy that will be flexible in its contractual arrangements with creators.

Somewhat related is IDW Publishing's annoucement that it's going to sell downloads of its comics (in pdf format) for $1.99 each.  The post here seems to suggest the consumer choice will be digital for 1.99 versus more for the floppy (paper).  Unfortunately for IDW it's not that simple — the people buying paper don't necessarily want to move to the web (and those that do may already be obtaining illegal copies of the books, a practical issue for the publisher to grapple with) and those that read webcomics (largely for free) may not value these comics in the same way.  And since ultimately the web audience is much larger than the buying monthly comic books audience I don't see this working well for IDW…

UPDATED

Wow – well Valerie and her buddy Paul Debenedetto have some thin skins.  Read if you're in the mood for unnecessary drama.  Also for some ideas on what Marvel and DC might do in the post-Internet-eats-every-past-media-business-model world we're headed for, read Joey's new post.  I think his idea for their potential future business model is closer to the mark than he gives himself credit for.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Bye Bye Man Man

Got a note from James Duncan, the artist on Man Man this morning: 

Howdy XX,

Wasn’t sure if this was news worthy or not for the site, but Man-Man comes to an end today… after 7 years, 2 versions, and lots of work, we’ve finally taken a rest.  Matt’s still blogging, and working on his comics in print, and I’m going to doodle with my comic strip at www.kaesye.com, but for now we rest.  Anyways, I hope all is well, and thanks for supporting us when no one else did!

James

James and Matt are good peoples and Man Man was a good comic; a silly, but often quite witty spin on the superhero genre.  James’ art was always solid and Matt is an inventive writer.  Be sure to check out their new projects — I think their best stuff is still ahead of them.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Two Great Panels from Katsucon 15

Two great panels – first with Kris Straub, Dave Kellett, Rob Balder, Phil Foglio, Barb Fischer of Fragile Gravity, Nick Borkowicz of Art Fight High School, and Chris "Kilika" Malone of Blue & Blond.


Katsucon 15: Print, Web, or Both: What Should a Comic Artist Do? from kaiki on Vimeo.

Second with Michael "Mookie" Terracciano, Marty Day, Kris Straub, Dave Kellett, Brian Prindiville and Ross Nover and Brad Guigar.


Katuscon 15: How To Make Webcomics: From Sketch to Posting and All Points in Between. from kaiki on Vimeo.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Quarter Life Crisis?

I am a fan of John Allison — I’ve been reading Bobbins-Scary Go Round since literally within days of Day 1 online.  So I was curious to read the discussion on his blog about his thinking aloud about his current webcomic and possible permutations of it.  And I suppose the question of broader interest is — what kind of things take a quality webcomic (which SGR clearly is by leaps and bounds) to that higher xkcd/questionable content/pvp levels of success?

(John’s initial post titled State of the Onion is here, and a follow up post from today is here.)

Continue Reading

Uncategorized