The Webcomic List is going to have a vote for The Webcomic List Awards. It appears to open to all comics listed with the site and voting is open to all (or maybe those with membership on the site?).
Unlike other comic awards comics do not need to be nominated, all comics* included on this site are eligible for each category. Hopefully leading to a fair and unbiased vote.
Please read down the page and select one comic for each section. In order for your vote to count you will only be able to vote if you select a comic from section.